On May 1, 1990, at Atlanta in Atlanta–Fulton County Stadium, Lilliquist became one of the few pitchers to have a multi-homer game when he hit two home runs off Ron Darling in a Braves' 5–2 victory over the New York Mets.[6] His batting statistics for the Braves that season included eight hits in 23 at bats for a .348 batting average, two home runs and three runs batted in with a .609 slugging percentage. However, his pitching had declined since his rookie year.
San Diego Padres
With a 6.28 ERA and two wins and eight losses in 11 starts, the Braves traded Lilliquist to the San Diego Padres for Mark Grant on July 12, 1990. Lilliquist's only career MLB complete game and shutout occurred on August 12, 1990, in a 9–0 defeat of the Houston Astros. He allowed four hits while striking out three.[7] With the Padres that season, he fared better, posting a 4.33 ERA.
Spending most of the 1991 season in the minor leagues, the Padres assigned Lilliquist to the Las Vegas Stars of the Pacific Coast League. Here, he allowed 142 hits in 105 IP and 33 games for 5.38 ERA, contributing as both a starter and reliever. With the Padres, he allowed 14 earned runs in 14+1⁄3 IP for an 8.79 ERA.
Cleveland Indians
The Cleveland Indians claimed Lilliquist off waivers from the Padres on November 22, 1991. He converted to full-time relief duty in 1992. Here, he posted some of his career-best numbers, including ERA, H/9, and walks plus hits per inning pitched (WHIP). In 71 games, he pitched 61+2⁄3 innings, allowed just 39 hits for 5.7 H/9, 0.924 WHIP and a 2.25 ERA. His 71 appearances placed fourth in the American League (AL) among pitchers. He also finished 22 games and saved six.
Continuing on his success in 1993, Lilliquist appeared in 56 games, posting a 2.25 ERA, 1.297 WHIP while saving ten games and finishing 28. His final year in Cleveland saw his ERA rise to 4.91 in 1994.
Boston Red Sox
He signed as a free agent with the Boston Red Sox before the 1995 season, but could not replicate his success in Cleveland. He appeared in 28 games while posting a 6.26 ERA. The Red Sox released him in July, making him a free agent.
Los Angeles Dodgers and Cincinnati Reds
The Los Angeles Dodgers signed Lilliquist on August 1, 1995, and assigned him to their AAA minor league affiliate, the Albuquerque Dukes. They never called him up to the major leagues. He again became a free agent following the season and signed with the Cincinnati Reds for the 1996 season. The Reds assigned him to their AAA minor league affiliate, the Indianapolis Indians, where he appeared in 47 games – all as a reliever – and posted a 2.60 ERA. The Reds called Lilliquist up to the major leagues, where he appeared in five games. His last MLB game was on September 6, 1996, against the San Francisco Giants, where he faced one batter and gave up a hit.[8]
Lilliquist next coached in the St. Louis Cardinals organization. In 2002, he served as the pitching coach for the Johnson City Cardinals of the Rookie League, where his pitching staff posted a 5.04 ERA and 7.8 strikeouts per 9 innings pitched (K/9) in 67 games.[9] The next season, he handled the same role for the Class A Peoria Chiefs. This team posted a 3.48 ERA and 5.8 K/9 in 138 games.[10]
Lilliquist spent the next four seasons as the pitching coach for the Class A Palm Beach Cardinals of the Florida State League (FSL) in Jupiter, Florida. His clubs twice made the playoffs. Palm Beach won the 2005 FSL Championship as the pitching staff registered the league's second-best ERA at 3.94.[1] He then contributed as the Cardinals' pitching coordinator from 2008–10, helping to rehabilitate injured pitchers at the club's spring training complex in Jupiter.[11]
The Cardinals named Lilliquist as the Cardinals major league bullpen coach on November 2, 2010.[11] Late in the Cardinals' 2011World Series–championship season, he temporarily replaced incumbent pitching coach Dave Duncan, who took a leave of absence for family reasons. On January 6, 2012, the Cardinals announced that Lilliquist would permanently replace Duncan, whose future remained uncertain.[12] On October 3, 2017, the Cardinals announced that Lilliquist would not return to the team for the 2018 season.[13]
Washington Nationals
The Washington Nationals named Lilliquist as their major league pitching coach on November 9, 2017.[14] On May 2, 2019, the Nationals announced that they had fired Lilliquist immediately after the conclusion of that evening's game and had replaced him with Nationals minor league pitching coordinator Paul Menhart.[15][16]
Personal life
During the offseason, Lilliquist resides in Vero Beach, Florida. Claudia Ferrari Lilliquist married him in 2014 and divorced him in 2018. He has two children, Derek and Alexandria.