In 1910 Keliher lost his bid for reelection, first losing in the Democratic primary,[6] and in the general election as an independent candidate,[7] losing both times to William F. Murray.[8]
Sheriff of Suffolk County
On April 11, 1917, the incumbent sheriff of Suffolk County, "Honest John" Quinn, died from diabetes.[9] On April 18, 1917 Governor McCall submitted Keliher's name to the Executive Council to fill the vacancy.[10] Keliher's appointment was approved by the Executive Council and he was sworn into office on May 3, 1917.[11] On November 6, 1917[12] Keliher was elected in his own right and re-elected in every election until 1938.[2]
1917 Massachusetts Constitutional Convention
In 1916 the Massachusetts legislature and electorate approved the calling of a Constitutional Convention.[13] In May 1917 Keliher was elected to serve as a member of the convention, representing Massachusetts' 11th Congressional District.
Electoral defeat and death
In September 1938 Keliher ran in the primary for renomination as sheriff of Suffolk County. After the returns showed that he was losing the election, he had a heart attack and died[14][15] in Boston.
Bibliography
Journal of the Constitutional Convention of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts (1919) pp. 7–8, 865, 971.
The Municipal Register for 1918 City of Boston (1918) p. 110.
Who's who in State Politics, 1908 Practical Politics (1908) p. 14.
^ abcWho's who in State Politics, 1908, Boston, MA: Practical Politics, 1908, p. 14
^ ab"John A. Keliher; Sheriff in Boston Since 1917 Dies While Losing Renomination", The New York Times (Special to The New York Times), New York, NY, p. 22, September 22, 1938
^ abJournal of the Constitutional Convention of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts, Boston, MA: Wright & Potter printing co., state printers, 1919, p. 8
^Journal of the Constitutional Convention of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts, Boston, MA: Wright & Potter printing co., state printers, 1919, pp. 865, 971
^"Both Lose Renomination: Keliher and O'Connell Defeated in Massachusetts Primaries. Majority of the Delegates to Democratic State Convention Will Go Uninstructed.", The Washington Post, Washington, DC, p. 3, September 28, 1910
^Murray Speaks in His Home District: Buckley Predicts He Will Sweep District. Keliher Has Three Rallies, Two of Them in Charlestown, Boston, MA: The Boston Daily Globe, November 5, 1910, p. 4
^"Foss Wins By 22,000 In Massachusetts; But the Rest of the Democratic State Ticket Has Probably Been Defeated.", The New York Times, New York, NY, p. 2, November 9, 1910
^"Honest John" Quinn Is Dead: Sheriff Yields Suddenly at the Charles-St Jail Long A Familiar and Genial Figure in Boston Politics, Boston, MA: The Boston Globe, April 12, 1917, p. 1
^Keliher Given Quinn's Berth: Sheriff Until Jan 1 With Election in Meantime Far-Reaching Political Effects Likely--Republicans Angry, Boston, MA: The Boston Globe, April 19, 1917, p. 13
^It's Now Sheriff John A. Keliher: Ex-Congressman Sworn In and Visits Jail Reappoints Deputies--Agrees to Sit in Constitutional Convention, Boston, MA: The Boston Globe, May 4, 1917, p. 11
^The Municipal Register for 1918, Boston, MA: The City of Boston, 1917, p. 110
^Journal of the Constitutional Convention of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts, 1919, pp. 7–8
^"John A. Keliher; Sheriff in Boston Since 1917 Dies While Losing Renomination", The New York Times, p. 23, September 22, 1938
^J. A Keliher, Sheriff, Dies In Bay State Suffolk County Official Had Held Post Since 1917; Congressman 4 Terms; Ran For Mayor, Hartford, CT: The Hartford Courant, September 22, 1938, p. 4